My blog has been a little review heavy lately as I try to catch up on talking about books I’ve read over the last several months, so I’m getting back into Top 5 Tuesday with a topic that was too enticing to miss out on – my top 5 favourite series! I promise I’ll stick to the format guidelines next time, but it was so hard for me to narrow this list down that I’m not just cheating, I’m MASSIVELY CHEATING. Since it’s the 14th of September, here are fourteen of my favourites instead.
Top 5 Tuesday is a weekly meme hosted by Meeghan Reads! It was originally created by the wonderful Bionic Book Worm. This week’s topic:
SEPTEMBER 14TH – Top Five Fourteen Favourite Series of All Time
Captive Prince Series by C.S. Pacat
What is it? A three-book fantasy romance about Prince Damen, who is betrayed by his half-brother and by his lover as they seize power in a coup. Stripped of his identity and sent to serve an enemy prince as a pleasure slave, Damen is soon caught up in a power play and must work with Laurent to survive and save his country.
Why do I love it? I got into this series back when it was being posted in updates on Livejournal and yes, my old livejournal username may be among those thanked for reading/commenting in the acknowledgments, so this holds a special place in my heart. It’s been thrilling to see the series published and to watch it achieve mainstream success. The first half of the first book is definitely something that will, understandably, turn people off; it’s very rapey and there’s other content that is definitely not what you expect in a romance. If you do decide to keep reading though, the series moves past this and become an enjoyable guilty pleasure with some actual emotional depth. The relationship that grows betwen Damen and Laurent is intense and worthy of shipping and Pacat keeps us guessing about how much each character knows. I also love the political intrigue of this world and the sense of tension throughout. It’s very clear that Pacat was inspired by my favourite author (further up the list) and you can see where she’s borrowed from Dunnett in an affectionate pastiche.
Favourite Book: Kings Rising
Least Favourite Book: Captive Prince
The Imperial Radch Trilogy by Ann Leckie
What is it? The Hugo Award sci-fi trilogy about a millennia old startship AI that inhabits the body of a single human “ancillary” named Breq. As the starship Justice of Toren, she once had thousands of bodies (ancillaries) at her disposal and was connected at all times to her crew, but 20 years ago a betrayal left Justice of Toren isolated and (more or less) human. Now she’s out for revenge.
Why do I love it? This series is one of the most unique I’ve ever read. The worldbuilding is exceptional with Leckie giving us details about the Radchaai Empire’s customs, taboos, and language, and I loved that this series zags when you expect it to zig. Instead of getting bigger and more explosive with its storylines as the series goes on, the Imperial Radch trilogy focuses on character development and sharp social critique. While the use of all she/her pronouns (the Radchaai language and society is unconcerned with gender) is initially jarring, I ultimately found it really effective.
Favourite Book: Ancillary Sword
Least Favourite Book: Ancillary Justice
Teixcalaan Series by Arkady Martine
What is it? Arkady Martine won the Hugo Award for Best Novel for her intelligent space opera A Memory Called Empire. Its sequel, A Desolation Called Peace, was published earlier this year. When Ambassador Mahit Dzmare arrives at the center of the Teixcalaani Empire, she learns that her predecessor has died and that his death may not have been an accident. Now, Mahit must discover who is behind the murder, rescue herself, and save her Station from Teixcalaan’s unceasing expansion.
Why do I love it? A Desolation Called Peace is one of the best books I’ve read all year and I loved A Memory Called Empire as well. Both are almost intimidatingly smart science-fiction that tackle colonization in a very realistic way, especially through ambassador Mahit Dzmare who both loves the Empire’s cultural output and hates its reach. She wants so badly to belong, but also hates that she has this desire and knows that in the eyes of the Empire’s citizens she will always be a barbarian outsider. It makes for delicious internal conflict, even as Mahit also feels a connection to her Teixcalaan attaché, Three Seagrass. The worldbuilding is outstanding and the politics and plotting are clever and intricate.
Favourite Book: A Desolation Called Peace
Least Favourite Book: A Memory Called Empire
The Shades of Magic Series by V.E. Schwab
What is it? A fantasy trilogy about one of the last magicians, who has the coveted ability to travel between parallel Londons; Red, Grey, White, and, once upon a time, Black. Officially Kell, the adopted son of the Maresh King, is an ambassador between courts and worlds, but unofficially he’s a smuggler. When an exchange goes awry, the consequences of his dangerous hobby catch up to Kell and the fate of all Londons may lie in the balance.
Why do I love it? A lot of V.E. Schwab’s books tend to get stuck in what I think of as 4.25 star territory. They’re good, they’re definitely enjoyable, but there’s just something missing. There can also be a sameness to her female protagonists. I adored this series though. Perhaps partly because it’s written in fantasy early 19th century, partly the parallel Londons setting, and partly because I love Kell with his peculiar coat and furrowed-brow and bond with his brother Rhy, this series hooked me. It’s fast-paced, high-stakes, and tremendously fun.
Favourite Book: A Conjuring of Light
Least Favourite Book: A Darker Shade of Magic/A Gathering of Shadows
The Wayfarers Series by Becky Chambers
What is it? The beloved cozy sci-fi series about characters from different species and representing a wide range of genders and sexualities coming together in understanding. Hopeful, optimistic, and sure to break a reading slump.
Why do I love it? Wayfarers is such a comforting warm hug of a read. The books are character, rather than plot, driven and Chambers builds an inventive world populated by species that have a wide range of appearances, customs, taboos, and rituals. Her books are often about the families you choose, rather than the ones you’re born into, and are about daring to hope and to try and do better.
Favourite Book: A Closed and Common Orbit
Least Favourite Book: Record of a Spaceborn Few
The Broken Earth Trilogy by N.K. Jemisin
What is it? N.K. Jemisin made history when she became the first person to win the Hugo Award for Best Novel three years in a row and the first person to win for all three books in a trilogy. Her groundbreaking dystopia is about a world where mass climate events wiping out chunks of civilization every few generations. Some individuals (known as orogenes) have the power to control and create earthquakes, but they are feared, used, and brainwashed from a young age to obey. When her husband murders their young son and kidnaps their daughter, Essun pursues her surviving family through a deadly, dying world.
Why do I love it? This series is a masterpiece and Jemisin deserved every one of her Hugo Awards. Jemisin’s lyrical prose and complex, fully-realized world are reasons enough to read the Broken Earth Trilogy, but I also love her characters, who are not always likeable but always understandable. Protagonist Essun especially has a tremendous character arc throughout the series. Intelligent, diverse, and well-written science-fiction.
Favourite Book: The Fifth Season/The Stone Sky
Least Favourite Book: Obelisk Gate
The Divine Cities Trilogy by Robert Jackson Bennett
What is it? Robert Jackson Bennett’s fantasy trilogy about a fictional continent where the roles of the oppressor and the oppressed have been reversed. Once near-omnipotent beings conquered and enslaved the neighbouring island nation of Saypur. But when the Saypuri found a way to kill the divinities, they emerged as a military power occupying the continent. Officially Saypuri spy Shara Komayd is visiting the continent on a diplomatic assignment. Unofficially she’s investigating a murder and discovers a plot to try to restore a divine regime.
Why do I love it? Robert Jackson Bennett is one of the few white men writing fantasy that I trust to write women well. I absolutely adore his vividly rendered characters! In City of Stairs he gave us Shara, a glasses-wearing, tea-drinking, quiet and clever WoC spy. In City of Blades we got General Turyin Mulaghesh, a foul-mouthed, one-armed, middle-aged female soldier. His worldbuilding is first-rate (are you sensing a pattern in my favourite series yet?) as it incorporates the world’s mythology about their dead divinities and I was engaged throughout.
Favourite Book: City of Stairs/City of Blades
Least Favourite Book: City of Miracles
The Winternight Trilogy by Katherine Arden
What is it? Set in medieval Russia and incorporating elements of Russian mythology and folklore, the Winternight Trilogy is a historical fantasy about a free-spirited nobleman’s daughter, Vasya Petrovna, who is able to see and communicate with mythological creatures.
Why do I love it? I’m not someone who does much in the way of seasonal reading but The Bear and the Nightingale is the perfect winter read. I just want to curl up under a blanket with a cup of hot chocolate and watch snow fall outside when I read this series! I’m also not big on fairy tales and retellings but I absolutely loved these books. The prose has a lyrical enchanting quality to it and Arden writes in a way that appeals to the senses, richly recreating the world of medieval Russia through imagery. I found the tension between the Orthodox church and the old traditions based in folklore and slavic myths intriguing, and I loved the fully-realized characters, especially Vasya.
Favourite Book: The Bear and the Nightingale/The Winter of the Witch
Least Favourite Book: The Girl in the Tower
The Raven Cycle by Maggie Stiefvater
What is it? A contemporary YA fantasy trilogy about five Virginia teens on a quest to find the Welsh king Owain Glendower who is thought to be buried along the ley line, of Henrietta, Virginia, and wake him from his slumber.
Why do I love it? This series! I have a lot of feelings about this series. I love that the books are focused on friendship and that the author even had a post-it nearby as she wrote to help her remember that “the worst thing that could happen was that they could stop being friends.” YA as a genre can be so concerned with romance. Even though there’s romance here and I enjoyed the romance, it always felt like it was secondary to this epic friendship between a group of teenagers from different upbringings. As someone who loves fantasy I was also really wrapped up in the magical and destiny elements of the story, and how atmospheric the writing is, but the reason this quartet works so well is its wonderful characters.
Favourite Book: The Dream Thieves/Blue Lily, Lily Blue
Least Favourite Book: The Raven King
The Murderbot Diaries by Martha Wells
What is it? The Hugo award-winning series of novellas (and one full-length novel!) about a part human and part bot, agender security unit. Although it lives in a world where it is treated as sentient property by the company that controls it, this SecUnit (who privately refers to itself as Murderbot), has hacked the governor module that tells it what to do, allowing it to make cho
Why do I love it? I don’t know if I’ve ever related to a character more than Murderbot. All Murderbot really wants is to be left alone to binge-watch its shows in peace, half-ass its security job, and not have to talk to anyone, but the humans it’s supposed to be working for keep getting into trouble and Murderbot keeps saving their lives. Murderbot’s first-person point-of-view is snarky, self-deprecating, and honest, but also, at times, surprisingly touching. The books are well-plotted, fast-paced, competence kink as Murderbot uses its proficiency to protect the humans it definitely doesn’t care about. Nope, no caring at all to be seen…
On a personal note, there are entire essays that could be written about Murderbot and the queer community. As an asexual person, I normally get annoyed at robot/androids being considered ace representation since it plays into cold, aloof, inhuman stereotypes that asexuals face, but I would be 100% okay with being represented by Murderbot. I’ve had conversations with friends in the queer community and the owner of my local SFF indie bookstore about how many asexuals and some trans and non-binary people connect with this character, which is pretty special.
Favourite Book: Artificial Condition (maybe? I love them all)
Least Favourite Book: Network Effect, but I did read it during quarantine so it deserves a re-read in more normal times.
The Doctrine of Labyrinths Series by Sarah Monette
What is it? Better known as Katherine Addison, who wrote The Goblin Emperor, this is Sarah Monette’s first fantasy series about a dysfunctional gay wizard, Felix Harrowgate, and his cat burglar half-brother from an equally dismal past, Mildmay. Comprising four books, it’s primarily about the gradual process of recovery from trauma. The characters never really get over what has happened to them, so much as try to process and work through it (in very much a two steps forward, one step back kind of way) to slowly, eventually, heal. There are massive content warnings for this series though so I advise being aware of what you’re getting yourself into.
Why do I love it? I absolutely love this series and am heartbroken that it’s out of print. Please ignore the covers that make it look like a bad paranormal romance and just lose yourself in the fascinating worldbuilding that strongly features labyrinths and Monette’s distinct voices that she has for alternating first-person chapters from Felix and Mildmay’s POV. Mildmay is one of my all-time favourite characters and I love the complicated, co-dependent and not always healthy bond he has with his half-brother throughout. From Goodreads it looks like this is a series you either love or hate with very little in between, so it may not be for you but it was very much for me.
Favourite Book: The Virtu and The Mirador
Least Favourite Book: Corambis
The Amberlough Dossier by Lara Elena Donnelly
What is it? Deeply relevant to recent political events, this fantasy trilogy is set in a secondary world reminiscent of Weimar Republic Berlin as the fascist One State Party rises to power. After his cover is blown on a mission, the emotionally and physically scarred spy Cyril DePaul becomes a turncoat in order to preserve his life and that of his lover. Amberlough is an espionage thriller about people and the choices, and sacrifices, they make under pressure.
Why do I love it? Donnelly’s prose is exquisite; atmospheric and sensual it creates a richly imagined sense of place. I absolutely love the moral ambiguity of this world and how realistic it is that this series is about people making choices and deciding what they value the most, whether it’s themselves, their partners, or a democratic society. The dance of a relationship between Cyril and Aristide Makricosta, a smuggler and emcee of the cabaret, as they compartmentalize and avoid talking about their feelings is a highlight. I have also never been as tense reading a book as I was Amberlough. The aura of danger as the book goes on and the water rises around our characters is terrifying but compelling and I couldn’t put it down! The series is brought to an incredibly satisfying conclusion as well, that feels earned and appropriate.
Favourite Book: Amberlough/Amnesty
Least Favourite Book: Armistice
The Six of Crows Duology by Leigh Bardugo
What is it? A YA Fantasy duology in which criminal prodigy Kaz Brekker gathers a crew of misfits to pull off a heist that could make them rich beyond their wildest dreams…if it doesn’t kill them first. An absolute masterpiece. I literally don’t trust people who didn’t enjoy this series.
Why do I love it? This is the series I universally recommend, regardless of age, gender, and reading preferences. People who don’t usually read YA or Fantasy have enjoyed it. People who don’t usually read period have enjoyed it. It’s just that good! The plotting is impeccable. The stakes get higher and higher as the books go on and they’re also intensely personal, with Bardugo placing each character in situations that personally test them and push them to their limits. The dynamics between characters are fabulous as their relationships develop and grow, and Kaz and Inej in particular are absolutely wonderful to watch. Each of the characters in their own right (okay, except maybe Matthias because really who cares?) are engaging and well developed and I would read a spin-off on any one of them. I could re-read this series forever, and probably will.
What is it? It will surprise absolutely no one to learn that my favourite series of all time is the Lymond Chronicles. Written by Dorothy Dunnett in the 1960s/70s, this is a dense six-book historical fiction epic that spans ten years of European history. In 1547 the exiled Scottish nobleman Francis Crawford of Lymond returns to his homeland to redeem his reputation and protect Scotland, and its child Queen, from the English threat. Dunnett was made an Officer of the Order of the British Empire for services to literature and she is counted as an influence by authors such as Katherine Arden, Juliet Marillier, C.S. Pacat, Ellen Kushner, Guy Gavriel Kay, and Max Gladstone.
Why do I love it? These books are an experience. You spend the first fifty to a hundred pages of the first book in the series, The Game of Kings, wondering what’s going on and what you’ve gotten yourself into but still weirdly enjoying the ride, and then the last third hits you with all of the feels and you finally gain some understanding of the often infuriating enigmatic protagonist.
The fandom might be a cult (a very nice, very well-intentioned cult, eager for new members to delight in its niche interest) and the author throws you into the deep-end with her untranslated or referenced quotes of medieval songs and poetry, but once you move beyond that this series is one of the most brilliant, affecting, intelligent things I have ever or will ever read.
The prose sometimes makes you put the book down to marvel at Dorothy Dunnett’s skill and envy the way she can turn a phrase. The way she uses perspective, only a handful of times placing us into the mind of Francis Crawford, and mostly making us see him through the unreliable eyes of others, is masterful, as is her ability to build and maintain tension. It’s the characters themselves and the dynamics between them that make this such a delight though. As much as I sometimes want to slap our handsome, sharp-tongued polyglot of a protagonist, I mostly adore him and just want him to have happiness, and possibly a long nap.
Favourite Book: The Game of Kings and Pawn in Frankincense
Least Favourite Book: The Ringed Castle
As you can see, I have a lot of thoughts about series! These are my absolute favourites, the ones I look forward to re-read and gleaning more from the next time around. Have you read any of these? What are your favourites series?
Thanks for reading!